GMOFORUM.AGROBIOLOGY.EU :  Phorum 5 The fastest message board... ever.
Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListNew TopicSearchLog In
Checkbiotech: EU's anti-GM stance is unsustainable, says study
Posted by: Prof. Dr. M. Raupp (IP Logged)
Date: September 30, 2005 07:28AM ; ;

Europe?s opposition to genetically modified ingredients will significantly
increase producers? costs over the next three years as it becomes ever
harder to secure GM-free supplies, says a new report, September 2005 by
Chris Mercer.

Margarine producers will be some of the worst affected, with sourcing of
non-GM ingredients likely to add more than 16 per cent to raw materials
costs in the next one to three years, says a new report commissioned by
Agricultural Biotechnology Europe (ABE).

This increase, the report says, means margarine producers could be paying an
extra ?85m in raw materials costs to sustain non-GM policies ? currently
thought to cover about 70 per cent of EU margarine production.

Such a price rise could put intense pressure on producers' profit margins as
they also battle against soaring oil (plastics) and energy costs, as well as
the supply chain squeeze from retailers.

A major problem is the declining global supply of non-GM ingredients in the
key soybean and derivative sector, notably now Brazil has begun planting GM
soybeans. GM soybeans accounted for 23 per cent of total production in
Brazil in 2004.

This situation is forecast to significantly raise costs for going non-GM,
particularly in animal feed.

The report says sourcing non-GM soymeal and soy oil for animal feed is
already about 10 and 13 per cent more expensive respectively than sourcing
GM. The gap for both may widen to as much as 25 per cent in the next three

More problems are likely to emerge in enzyme production, the researchers
say, as the European Commission looks to create a new Enzyme Directive.

This means more enzymes would be defined as additives, forcing producers to
include them on ingredients labels. Products containing a number of the
GM-derived enzymes currently used in bakery, dairy and other sectors may
therefore fall foul of consumers' anti-GM attitudes.

The anti-GM climate within the EU as a whole was also highlighted as a major
obstacle to future enzyme development within the bloc, according to a recent
report on the European enzymes market by Frost & Sullivan.

The European Commission has so far given its approval to several GM
products, including sweetcorn, oilseed and one soybean type.

Yet, the European Council of Ministers has consistently failed to reach a
decision over GM ingredients. The body last week failed again to agree on
the Commission's latest approval, for GM maize 1507, after several countries
blocked the move.

The indecision means the Commission can now authorise the maize if it
chooses. Yet the anti-GM feeling among European consumers still presents a
serious dilemma for the food industry.

Earlier this year, a survey polled by the UK's consumer magazine Which?
found that Britons feel even more strongly about GM foods than they did two
years ago.

More than six out of 10 people (61 per cent) were concerned about the use of
GM material in food production - up from 56 per cent in 2002. Around 68 per
cent wanted manufacturers to go one step further and source non-GM animal

Some major food producers operating in Europe, such as Heinz, and nearly all
major UK supermarkets, have begun to use non-GM status as a marketing tool
in itself.

But, the ABE-commissioned report points out that ?to date, consumers have
rarely been given the option of a choice between GM and non-GM alternatives
of the same product or faced price differentials between the two?.


Posted to Phorum via PhorumMail

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
This forum powered by Phorum.